Profiling of extracellular small RNAs highlights a strong bias towards non-vesicular secretion

Extracellular environment consists of a plethora of different molecules, including extracellular miRNA that can be secreted in association with extracellular vesicles (EVs) or soluble protein complexes (non-EVs). Yet, it is generally accepted that most of the biological activity is attributed to EV-associated miRNAs. The capability of EVs to transport cargoes has attracted much interest towards developing EVs as therapeutic short RNA carriers by using endogenous loading strategies for miRNA enrichment. Here, by overexpressing miRNA and shRNA sequences of interest in source cells and using size exclusion liquid chromatography (SEC) to separate the cellular secretome into EV and non-EV fractions, we saw that strikingly, <2% of all secreted overexpressed miRNA were found in association with EVs. To see whether the prominent non-EV miRNA secretion also holds true at the basal expression level of native miRNA transcripts, both fractions were further analysed by small RNA sequencing. This revealed a global correlation of EV and non-EV miRNA abundance to that of their parent cells and showed an enrichment only for miRNAs with a relatively low cellular expression level. Further quantification showed that similarly to the transient overexpression context, an outstanding 96.2-99.9% of total secreted miRNA at its basal level was secreted to the non-EV fraction. Yet, even though EVs contain only a fraction of secreted miRNAs, these molecules were found stable at 37{degrees}C in serum-containing environment, indicating that if sufficient miRNA loading to EVs is achieved, EVs can remain miRNA delivery-competent for a prolonged period of time. This study suggests that the passive endogenous EV loading strategy can be a relatively wasteful way of loading miRNA to EVs and active miRNA loading approaches are needed for developing advanced EV miRNA therapies in the future.