Effects of plants and biochar on the performance of treatment wetlands for removal of the pesticide chlorantraniliprole from agricultural runoff

Abstract Chlorantraniliprole (CAP), an emergent insecticide commonly replacing banned neonicotinoids, is used worldwide despite the risk of contaminating water bodies. Treatment wetlands (TWs) have shown great potential for mitigating various pesticides in agricultural runoff, but little is known about CAP removal. The aim of this study was to determine the effect of adding biochar to subsurface flow treatment wetlands (SSF TWs) and the performance of three macrophyte species (Phragmites australis subsp. americanus, Scirpus cyperinus and Sporobolus michauxianus) in CAP removal. Removal efficiency was monitored over a one-month period in water-saturated SSF mesocosms fed with synthetic agricultural runoff containing CAP. To reflect temporal changes in agricultural runoff dynamics, two CAP concentrations were used in influent: a peak concentration (4 μg/L) for the first week and a trace concentration (0.4 μg/L) for the three subsequent weeks. Results showed that mesocosms with biochar were very effective in removing CAP mass (90 to 99%) and remained so throughout the experimental period. On the other hand, the level of CAP removal achieved in planted mesocosms without biochar was low (less than 13%). Evapotranspiration contributed significantly to volume reduction, but no general pattern in CAP mass removal efficiency was detected among the planted treatments without biochar. However, planted treatments acted as buffer zones, accumulating CAP and reducing its peak mass in effluent. Evapotranspiration rates of Scirpus and Phragmites were higher than that of Sporobolus, resulting in a greater buffering effect. This study suggests that addition of biochar to SSF TW substrate is a promising approach for CAP mitigation in agricultural runoff, but long-term efficiency remains to be assessed.