Olive mill sludge may reduce water contamination by 4-chloro-2-methylphenoxyacetic acid (MCPA) in non-flooding but enhance it in flooding rice cropping agroecosystems

Abstract A field experiment covering three years was conducted to evaluate how composted olive mill sludge (OS) influenced MCPA's environmental fate in rice soils under six combinations of tillage and irrigation cultivation techniques: tillage and sprinkler irrigation without (TS) or with (TSOS) the addition of OS (80 Mg ha−1), no-tillage and sprinkler irrigation without (NTS) or with (NTSOS) OS, and tillage and continuous flooding without (TF) or with (TFOS) OS. The measurements made in the first and third years after OS application were taken to constitute the “direct” and “residual” effects, respectively. After OS amendment, Kd (partition coefficients) values in the direct year were lower by factors of 1.1, 1.3, and 1.9 in TSOS, NTSOS, and TFOS, respectively, relative to the corresponding unamended soils, and in the residual year by factors of 1.1 and 1.5 in TSOS and NTOS, but greater by a factor of 1.5 in TFOS, than in the corresponding unamended soils, respectively. The dissipation of MCPA was very fast under both anaerobic (t1/2 = 1.80–5.29 d) and aerobic (t1/2 = 2.23–9.42 d) incubation conditions. The field application of OS led to a decrease in MCPA persistence under both incubation conditions, especially in the TF case. However, while under aerobic conditions the half-life (t1/2) decreased after OS addition in the direct and residual years, under anaerobic condition it only decreased in the direct year. While the application of OS in TS and NTS led to less leaching of MCPA, in TF it led to 1.4 and 1.2 times more leaching losses of the herbicide for the direct and residual years, respectively. Therefore, the use of OS in rice production could be considered an effective strategy for reducing water contamination by MCPA in at least the short- and medium-terms after its application, but only under non-flooding crop management regimes irrespective of the tillage practice implemented.