MAFIA: Multi-layered Architecture For IoT-based Authentication

Multi-factor authentication (MFA) systems are being deployed for user authentication in online and personal device systems, whereas physical spaces mostly rely on single-factor authentication; examples are entering offices and homes, airport security, and classroom attendance. The Internet of Things (IoT) growth and market interest has created a diverse set of low-cost and flexible sensors and actuators that can be used for MFA. However, combining multiple authentication factors in a physical space adds several challenges, such as complex deployment, reduced usability, and increased energy consumption. We introduce MAFIA (Multi-layered Architecture For IoT-based Authentication), a novel architecture for co-located user authentication composed of multiple IoT devices. In MAFIA, we improve the security of physical spaces while considering usability, privacy, energy consumption, and deployment complexity. MAFIA is composed of three layers that define specific purposes for devices, guiding developers in the authentication design while providing a clear understanding of the trade-offs for different configurations. We describe a case study for an Automated Classroom Attendance System, where we evaluated three distinct types of authentication setups and showed that the most secure setup had a greater usability penalty, while the other two setups had similar attributes in terms of security, privacy, complexity, and usability but varied highly in their energy consumption.