Tropical Cyclone Winds from WindSat, AMSR2, and SMAP: Comparison with the HWRF Model

A new data set of tropical cyclone winds (‘TC-winds’) through rain as observed by the WindSat and AMSR2 microwave radiometers has been developed by making use of a linear combination of C- and X-band frequency channels. These winds, along with tropical cyclone winds from the SMAP L-band radiometer, are compared with the Hurricane Weather Research and Forecasting (HWRF) model. Due to differences in spatial scales between the satellites and the high-resolution HWRF model, resampling must be performed on the model winds before comparisons are done. Various ways of spatial resampling are discussed in detail, and an optimal method is determined. Additionally, resampled model winds must be temporally interpolated to the time of the satellite before direct comparisons are made. This interpolation can occasionally result in un-physical 2D wind fields, especially for fast-moving storms. To assist users with this problem, a methodology for handling un-physical wind features is detailed. Results of overall comparisons between the satellites and HWRF for 19 storms between 2017 and 2020 displayed consistent storm features, with overall average biases less than 1 m/s and standard deviations below 4 m/s for all tropical cyclone winds between 10 and 60 m/s. Differences were seen when the comparisons were performed separately for the Atlantic and Pacific basins, with biases and standard deviations between the satellites and HWRF showing better agreement in the Atlantic. The impact of rain on the satellite wind retrievals is discussed, and no systematic bias was seen between the three sensors, despite the fact that they use different frequency channels in their tropical cyclone winds-through-rain retrieval algorithms.