Some comments on the paper analysis of experiments on calorimetry of LiOD/D2O electrochemical cells, R.H. Wilson et al., J. Electroanal. Chem., 332 (1992) 1☆

Abstract We comment here on the title paper and find that it is a series of misconceptions and misrepresentations of previous reports by Fleischmann, Pons and co-workers. It is shown that the conclusions reached by the authors lead to gross errors in the prediction of the observed responses of the electrochemical calorimeters described in the original work and that the correct methods of analyses are indeed those we originally described as well as those which have been outlined in subsequent publications. We find that the authors have not validated their own methods and have not provided sufficient information to allow assessment of their work.