Differences in plumage coloration predict female but not male territorial responses in three antbird sister species pairs

Social selection, via intra- and intersexual competition for sexual (e.g. mates) and/or nonsexual (e.g. territories) resources, is thought to drive the evolution of ornaments in both sexes. However, the relative importance of intra- and intersexual competition in promoting the evolution of female and male ornamentation and, hence, sexual dichromatism remains poorly understood. We addressed this issue in antbirds (Thamnophilidae), a radiation of sexually dichromatic passerines wherein eumelanic plumage patches have evolved multiple times in both sexes. In antbirds, the degree of sexual dichromatism differs between closely related species primarily due to eumelanic dark patches in either sex. If eumelanic patches evolved by social selection, individuals of species bearing more conspicuous eumelanic patches should display stronger territorial responses regardless of their sex. Using playback experiments, we simulated three conspecific territorial intrusion types – a social pair, a female and a male – and measured responses by social pairs of two sister species pairs exhibiting greater interspecific differences in female coloration and one sister species pair exhibiting greater interspecific differences in male coloration. We found that females of species bearing more conspicuous eumelanic patches responded more strongly than females of species bearing less conspicuous eumelanic patches, but only towards simulated female and/or male intruders. However, males responded similarly to all intrusions regardless of interspecific coloration differences. Our results suggest that eumelanic patches in antbirds may function as ornaments and that greater female ornamentation may function in intra- and intersexual contexts and reflect stronger social competition in ornamented females for territories and, possibly, mates. In contrast, in species pairs with greater interspecific differences in male ornamentation, territorial competition may occur predominantly among males and female mate choice may drive the evolution of male ornamentation. Our study highlights that social selection pressures acting on both sexes may drive the evolution of contrasting sexual dichromatism patterns.