Sound Practices: An Exploratory Study of Building and Monitoring Multiple-Choice Exams at Canadian Undergraduate Medical Education Programs.

PURPOSE Written examinations such as multiple-choice question (MCQ) exams are a key assessment strategy in health professions education (HPE), frequently used to provide feedback, determine competency, or for licensure decisions. However, traditional psychometric approaches for monitoring the quality of written exams, defined as items that are discriminant and contribute to increase the overall reliability and validity of the exam scores, usually warrant larger samples than are typically available in HPE contexts. The authors conducted a descriptive exploratory study to document how undergraduate medical education (UME) programs ensure the quality of their written exams, particularly MCQs. METHOD Using a qualitative descriptive methodology, the authors conducted semistructured interviews with 16 key informants from 10 Canadian UME programs in 2018. Interviews were transcribed, anonymized, coded by the primary investigator, and co-coded by a second team member. Data collection and analysis were conducted iteratively. Research team members engaged in analysis across phases, and consensus was reached on the interpretation of findings via group discussion. RESULTS Participants focused their answers around MCQ related practices, reporting using several indicators of quality such as alignment between items and course objectives and psychometric properties (difficulty and discrimination). The authors clustered findings around 5 main themes: processes for creating MCQ exams; processes for building quality MCQ exams; processes for monitoring the quality of MCQ exams; motivation to build quality MCQ exams; and suggestions for improving processes. CONCLUSIONS Participants reported engaging multiple strategies to ensure the quality of MCQ exams. Assessment quality considerations were integrated throughout the development and validation phases, reflecting recent work regarding validity as a social imperative.