Triple sulfur isotope relationships during sulfate-driven anaerobic oxidation of methane

Abstract Sulfate-driven anaerobic oxidation of methane (SD-AOM) plays a critical role in regulating the global methane budget. Determination of the diagnostic triple isotope exponent θ 33 ( ≡ ln 33 ⁡ α / ln 34 ⁡ α ) for SD-AOM can help to identify and quantify microbial sulfate reduction via SD-AOM in the environment. The history of Earth's surface redox conditions can also be examined through the measurement of triple sulfur isotope compositions in sedimentary rocks. Due to difficulties in both culturing anaerobic methanotrophs and sampling pore-water sulfate in SD-AOM-dominated environments, however, the θ 33 values for the processes of SD-AOM have not been constrained. We propose that a set of modern cold-seep associated barite samples with low Δ δ 18 O / Δ δ 34 S values bear a record of residual pore-water sulfate during SD-AOM, and therefore the triple sulfur isotope composition of these barites can be used to deduce θ 33 values. We applied a 1-D diagenetic reaction–transport model to fit Δ 33 S and δ ′ 34 S results from modern cold seep barites collected from five sites in the Gulf of Mexico. Based on revealed negative correlations ( R 2 = 0.77 ) between Δ 33 S and δ ′ 34 S values we calculated an upper-limit θ 33 value of 0.5100 to 0.5112 (±0.0005) given a 1000 ln 34 ⁡ α value of − 30 ‰ to − 10 ‰ . This θ 33 value is distinctively lower than that of organoclastic sulfate reduction (OSR) in marine environments where the diagnostic isotope fractionation ( 1000 ln 34 ⁡ α ) is typically more negative than that of SD-AOM. In addition, cold seep barite data display a negative Δ 33 S – δ ′ 34 S correlation whereas pore-water sulfates of all OSR-dominated settings show a positive one. Therefore, the diagnostic triple-sulfur isotope exponent and associated negative Δ 33 S – δ ′ 34 S correlation may allow for the identification of SD-AOM in sedimentary records.