Performance Analysis of 10 Models of 3D LiDARs for Automated Driving

Automated vehicle technology has recently become reliant on 3D LiDAR sensing for perception tasks such as mapping, localization and object detection. This has led to a rapid growth in the LiDAR manufacturing industry with several competing makers releasing new sensors regularly. With this increased variety of LiDARs, each with different properties such as number of laser emitters, resolution, field-of-view, and price tags, a more in-depth comparison of their characteristics and performance is required. This work compares 10 commonly used 3D LiDARs, establishing several metrics to assess their performance. Various outstanding issues with specific LiDARs were qualitatively identified. The accuracy and precision of individual LiDAR beams and accumulated point clouds are evaluated in a controlled environment at distances from 5 to 180 meters. Reflective targets were used to characterize intensity patterns and quantify the impact of surface reflectivity on accuracy and precision. A vehicle and pedestrian mannequin were also used as additional targets of interest. A thorough assessment of these LiDARs is given with their potential applicability for automated driving tasks. The data collected in these experiments and analysis tools are all shared openly.