New insights into the anti-disproportionation mechanism of ZrCo alloying with Ti, Hf, Sc, Cu, and Fe elements

Abstract First-principles calculations were performed to investigate the effects of alloying substitutions (i.e. Ti, Hf, Sc, Cu and Fe) on the anti-disproportionation ability of ZrCo alloy. For the first time, we revealed the disproportionation mechanism from the energy point of view and provided a new theoretical method to predict whether the substitution element has the ability to enhance the anti-disproportionation performance of ZrCo alloy. Based on the hydrogen atom occupancy behavior in ZrCoH3 and the results of our calculation of binding energy, the hydrogen atom migration model during hydrogenation and theoretical computational model were established. Through structural optimization, a series of stable 2 × 1 × 2 ZrCoH3 supercells were obtained, which contain four hydrogen atoms occupying 8e site and various substitution atoms with different amounts except for pure system. The binding energy of hydrogen atom in the 8e site and activation energy of diffusing from 8e site to 4c2 site of these ZrCoH3 supercells were calculated. The results showed that the substitution of Ti and Hf increased the binding energy of hydrogen atom in the 8e site, while the substitution of Fe, Cu and Sc decreased the binding energy of hydrogen atom in the 8e site. Meanwhile, both of Ti and Hf substitution reduced the activation energy of diffusing from 8e site to 4c2 site, while all of Fe, Cu and Sc substitution increased the activation energy of diffusing from 8e site to 4c2 site. These results indicated that hydrogen-induced disproportionation was the inherent property of ZrCo alloy, and element substitution can restrain or accelerate disproportionation by affecting both the binding energy and activation energy. With simultaneous consideration of the binding energy and activation energy, the effect of these alloying substitutions on the anti-disproportionation ability could be ascertained and the results were in good agreement with the previous theoretical and experimental results.