Assessment of Four Model-Based Surface Soil Temperature Products Unsing Global Dense in Situ Observations

Assessment of the model-based surface soil temperature (ST) products is very important for hydrometeorological and ecological applications, as well as model refinements. Distinguished from previous regional validations using only in situ observations from sparse networks, this study focused on the evaluation of model-based ST products by considering ground observations from 15 dense networks worldwide from April 2015 to December 2017 covering a wide range of ground conditions. Four model-based ST products were selected for the assessment, including the Modern-Era Retrospective Analysis for Research and Applications, version 2 (MERRA-2), the Goddard Earth Observing System Model version 5 Forward Processing (GEOS-5 FP), the ERA-Interim and its successor, the newly developed ERA5. The results indicate the GEOS-5 ST product slightly outperforms other ST products by showing an averaged ubRMSD of 1.84 K. All model-based ST products underestimate in situ ST with a negative bias. All four model-based ST products are demonstrated to well capture the temporal trends of ground observations with very promising $R$ values larger than 0.97. The ERA5 shows visible improvements compared to its predecessor ERA-Interim by exhibiting smaller ubRMSD, absolute bias and larger $R$ values. These findings are expected to provide useful suggestions for the enhancement and specific usage of the model-based ST products.