Activity of a SDHI fungicide penflufen and the characterization of natural-resistance in Fusarium fujikuroi

Abstract The occurrence of bakanae disease of rice caused by the fungus Fusarium fujikuroi in Zhejiang Province has become increasingly aggravated in recent years, concomitant with the development of resistance to the widely applied fungicides, prochloraz and phenamacril. In this study, the activity of a novel succinate dehydrogenase inhibitor (SDHI) fungicide, penflufen, against different fungi was evaluated in addition to the potential of penflufen in controlling F. fujikuroi infections. Penflufen exhibited good bioactivity against F. fujikuroi, but weak activity against Fusarium spp. and other investigated plant-pathogenic fungi including Colletotrichum spp. In addition to inhibiting mycelial growth, penflufen effectively inhibited F. fujikuroi conidium production. For germination, penflufen could effectively inhibit that of small conidia, but only delay the germination of large conidia. In addition, the sensitivity to penflufen among 100 F. fujikuroi isolates that were collected in areas that were never exposed to SDHIs was determined based on mycelium growth. Sensitivities surprisingly exhibited bimodal distributions, indicating the presence of natural resistance. Cross-resistance was not observed between penflufen in F. fujikuroi and two fungicides that have been extensively applied in field including prochloraz (a DMI) and phenamacril (a 2-cyanoacrylate fungicide), nor with the three SDHIs, fluopyram, benzovindiflupyr, and pydiflumetofen. Additional analysis identified five different point mutations in SDH-A (i.e., at residues 46, 225, 283, 430, and 586) of naturally resistant isolates. These results inform the potential application of the new SDHI fungicide penflufen for managing crop diseases and understanding possible resistance mechanisms among pathogens.