Assessing modified aluminum-based water treatment residuals as a plant-available phosphorus source

Abstract Inorganic phosphorus (P) fertilizers are a finite resource; alternative means of creating P fertilizers from current municipal and agricultural waste sources may reduce our reliance on phosphate rock mining, and improve waste disposal and nutrient cycling. Previous research demonstrated that organic aluminum water treatment residual composites (Al/O-WTR), created by mixing aluminum water treatment residuals (Al-WTR) with swine wastewater, have the potential to be a source of plant-available P. A greenhouse study was conducted to compare spring wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) growth with increasing application rates of swine wastewater-derived Al/O-WTR and commercial P fertilizer (both applied at 34, 67, and 135 kg P2O5 ha−1) in either sandy loam or sandy clay loam soil. Spring wheat straw and grain P uptake were comparable across all treatments in the sandy loam, while straw and grain P uptake were lower with Al/O-WTR in the sandy clay loam. The Al/O-WTR did not affect soil organic P concentrations, but did increase phosphatase activity in both soils. Increased phosphatase activity suggests that Al/O-WTR application stimulated microorganisms and enhanced the extent to which microbial communities mineralized Al/O-WTR-bound organic P. Overall, these results suggest that Al-WTR can be used to make P fertilizer, combining two “waste” products to create a useful product. Phosphorus harvesting via Al/O-WTR may be a feasible future alternative to mining phosphate rock, while avoiding unnecessary waste disposal and improving agricultural nutrient cycling.