Morbidity of schistosomiasis mansoni in the highlands of Madagascar and comparison of current sonographical classification systems

Abstract To study the morbidity of schistosomiasis mansoni in the highlands of Madagascar, a cross-sectional study examined the extent to which liver fibrosis occurred in a rural community. The Managil and the Cairo classification systems were used. A second purpose was to investigate the effect of the measurements of 2 different branches of the portal vein (either segmental or sub-segmental branches) on the resulting staging of morbidity using the Cairo classification system. In a rice farmer village, 656 inhabitants (95% of the total population) were parasitologically examined; 561 patients underwent sonographic work-up based on the Managil scoring system, and in 307 randomized patients the outer to outer diameters of both the segmental and the sub-segmental branches of the portal vein were measured and scored by the Cairo classification system. Overall prevalence of schistosomiasis mansoni in the study area in 1994 was 68·3%. Upon sonographic examination and scoring by the Managil system 23·4% of the population showed liver changes (Managil degree I/II/III, 20%/2·5%/0·9%). Measuring the subsegmental branches only and scoring by the Cairo classification, 19% of the study population were found to have liver changes, none with severe fibrosis. By contrast, 82% were found to have liver changes (Cairo degree 1/2/3, 70%/11%/2%) when the segmental branches were measured. The diameters of the subsegmental branches were about two-thirds of those of the segmental branches. Both the Cairo- and the Managil-examination protocols have pitfalls. Using the Cairo classification, a considerable systematic error in classifying morbidity is created by measuring different branches of the portal vein.