The preventability of death in road traffic fatalities with head injury in Victoria, Australia

Abstract Since 1992 the Consultative Committee on Road Traffic Fatalities in Victoria (CCRTF) has examined the medical management of patients who died following motor vehicle accidents. Three hundred and fifty-five fatalities with head injury occurring between 1 July, 1992 and 31 December 1997 were assessed by the CCRTF. They represented 79% of the total 449 fatalities examined by the Committee. Following examination of the complete medical records and multidisciplinary discussion, the Committee considered 237 (67%) of the 355 neurotrauma deaths to be non-preventable, 105 (30%) potentially preventable and 13 (4%) preventable. The present analysis excludes the non-preventable deaths in order to focus on preventable factors. Problems identified in the 118 patients pre-hospital included: no intubation; prolonged scene time; and no intravenous access; in 139 emergency room attendances: inappropriate reception including delay in arrival of a consultant, no neurosurgical consultation, no CT scan of the head, inadequate blood gases and oxygen monitoring, inadequate fluid resuscitation, delayed respiratory resuscitation and delayed despatch to the operating room; in 111 operating room visits: no ICP monitoring, inadequate fluid administration and inappropriate anaesthetic technique; and in 90 intensive care unit admissions: no ICP monitoring. Overall, 1745 individual problems in the various areas of care were identified, of which 1104 (63%) were judged to have contributed to death. Improved delivery and quality of trauma care could reduce the identified problems in emergency services and clinical management. Basic principles of trauma management remain the most important means of reducing morbidity and death following road trauma. The leadership role of the neurosurgeon in neurotrauma care is emphasised.