The impact of repeated insecticidal treatments on drift and benthos of a headwater stream

A small first-order, Appalachian Mountain stream received successive seasonal treatments with the insecticide, methoxychlor. Despite an application rate of 10 mg/1 methoxychlor for 4 hours, based on stream discharge, only a small fraction (1.6%) of the insecticide was exported to downstream reaches for a 31 h period during and following treatment. Most of the insecticide was incorporated into sediments of the streambed, which had residues ranging from 0.038 to 11.7 µg methoxychlor/g dry wt of sediments in June 1986 following treatments in December 1985 and March 1986. Despite low concentrations of methoxychlor measured in stream water (maximum = 128 µg/l) during the initial treatment, massive drift (> 950 000 organisms, and 70 g AFDM biomass) occurred from a stream area of about 144 m2. Numerically, collector-gatherer taxa (primarily Chironomidae) dominated drift (63 %) followed by shredders and predators; however, biomass of drift was dominated by shredders (48.9%), followed by predators and collector-gatherers. Compared with pre-treatment benthic abundances, insects were reduced by 75% following the initial treatment in December 1985, and 85% following an additional treatment in March 1986. Benthic abundances of non-insect taxa showed no significant changes. Benthic abundances of shredder, collector-filterer, and scraper functional groups exhibited significant decreases in the first month following treatment. Although benthic abundances of collector-gatherer and predator taxa were reduced by 48.6 and 40.5%, respectively, the reduction was not statistically significant because of high-sample variance. Comparisons of drift composition during the initial treatment with successive quarterly treatments (March 1986 to January 1988) reflected of ongoing pesticide disturbance of the biota as the community structure shifted from one consisting of a diverse insect and non-insect fauna toward one dominated by copepods, oligochaetes, Collembola, and chironomids.