Glycine receptors are not directly modulated by glutamate, AP5 or NMDA

Reproducibility of research data is a significant problem with more than 60% of biological and medical researchers reporting they have failed to reproduce published data. General acceptance of incorrect results can mean that future data is incorrectly interpreted and progress significantly interrupted. Thus, replication studies play an essential role in corroborating research findings and validating future research objectives. Here, we attempted to replicate data demonstrating the neurotransmitter glutamate, as well as NMDA and AP5, acts as positive allosteric modulators of the inhibitory glycine receptor. Notably, it was shown that the amplitude of miniature glycinergic currents recorded in spinal cord slices were reversibly enhanced when extracellular glutamate concentrations were increased by the glutamate transporter antagonist TBOA. This finding indicates that endogenous fluctuations in extracellular [glutamate] permits cross-talk between excitatory and inhibitory synapses and likely plays a role in setting the spinal inhibitory glycinergic tone and modulating baseline neurotransmission. We re-evaluated the data in primary cultured spinal cord neurons, spinal cord slice and Xenopus laevis oocytes expressing recombinant glycine receptors. Despite extensive efforts, we were unable to reproduce the finding that glutamate, AP5 or NMDA positively modulate glycine receptor currents. We paid careful attention to key aspects of the original study design, ensured rapid drug exposure by using fast-flow application and took into account receptor saturation and protocol deviations such as animal species. This study refutes the finding that glycine receptors are directly modulated by glutamate spill-over and suggests that glycinergic tone is independent of changes in excitatory activity.