MANAGEMENT OF OPEN TIBIAL FRACTURES WITH CIRCULAR FINE-WIRE FIXATORS: A STUDY OF FUNCTIONAL OUTCOME

Introduction Open tibial fractures are associated with an increased risk of infection. The infection rate increases with increasing severity and grade of fracture. Various management options available for fracture treatment are in turn associated with complications including infection. Circular fine-wire fixators cause minimal intra-operative soft tissue disruption and possibly have a better outcome and low complication rates. Objectives To analyse the effectiveness of circular fine-wire fixators in managing open tibial fractures and to determine the incidence of complications, particularly infection associated with use of these fixators. Methods A retrospective review of 34 open tibial fractures treated with circular fine-wire fixators [Ilizarov and Taylor Spatial Frame (TSF)] in a teaching hospital. Results We treated 34 patients (n=34) with fine-wire fixators. An Ilizarov frame was used for 19 (56%) and TSF was used for 16 (44%) patients. Mean patient age was 47.1 years. Seventy four percent had high energy while 26% had low energy injury. Consequently 4 (12%) had grade I, 3 (9%) had grade II, 6(17%) had grade IIIA and 21(62%) had grade IIIB injury as per the Gustilo-Anderson Classification. Forteen percent of patients had proximal, 17% had mid-shaft, 67% had distal tibial fractures respectively. Average time to union was 28.9 weeks. Grade IIIB fractures healed in 29.6 weeks. Fifty percent of these patients were full weight bearing immediately after surgery. 17 required soft tissue coverage and only two developed skin graft complications. Twelve (35%) had pin-site infection treated with antibiotics. There was one case of non-union and no reported mal-union or deep infections. Conclusion We report fewer complications with the use of fine-wire fixators. The infection rate is low and only limited to superficial tissues. Healing time is considerably reduced and patients are full weight bearing almost immediately. These devices are particularly effective in management of grade IIIB open distal tibial fractures with decreased time to union of tibia.