Interpreting strength parameters of strain-softening clay from shallow to deep embedment using ball and T-bar penetrometers

Abstract Full-flow penetrometers (ball and T-bar) are widely used for measurements of strength characteristics of clayey soils in offshore field investigations and laboratory tests. However, the accuracy of the estimated undrained shear strength is hampered by: (1) the drastic variation of the bearing factor for the penetrometer at shallow and transitional penetration depths where full-flow mechanisms are not achieved; and (2) the strain-softening of the soil, which results in a degradation of the estimated strength. This study conducted LDFE analyses to simulate the entire penetration process of full-flow penetrometers in strain-softening soils from shallow to deep embedment depths. Parametric studies were performed to investigate the effects of varied factors on the bearing factor and failure mechanism during the penetrometer penetration. Based on the LDFE analyses, empirical formulas are established to represent the critical penetration depths in the strain-softening soil, which are used to correct the bearing factor at shallow penetration depths. The discrepancies of the transitional failure mechanism and the trapped cavity bearing factor between ball and T-bar are emphasized. Finally, a back-analyses framework is proposed to estimate the strength parameters (including the original undrained shear strength prior to any strain-softening, and the strain-softening parameters) based on the measurements of the penetrometer during the first penetration from shallow to deep embedment depths. Through a series of model tests, the reliability of the back-analyses framework is validated.