Investigating the DNA methylation profile of e-cigarette use

Rationale and objectivesLittle evidence exists on the health effects of e-cigarette use. DNA methylation may serve as a biomarker for exposure and could be predictive of future health risk. We aimed to investigate the DNA methylation profile of e-cigarette use. MethodsAmong 117 smokers, 117 non-smokers and 116 non-smoking vapers, we evaluated associations between e-cigarette use and epigenome-wide methylation from saliva. We tested associations between e-cigarette use and methylation scores known to predict smoking and smoking-related disease. We assessed the ability of a methylation score for predicting e-cigarette use and for discriminating lung cancer. Measurements and Main Results7 CpGs were identified in relation to e-cigarette use at p<1x10-5 and none at p<5.91x10-8. 13 CpGs were associated with smoking at p<1x10-5 and one at p<5.91x10-8. CpGs associated with e-cigarette use were largely distinct from those associated with smoking. There was strong enrichment of known smoking-related CpGs in the smokers but not the vapers. A methylation score for e-cigarette use showed poor prediction internally (AUC 0.55, 0.41-0.69) and externally (AUC 0.57, 0.36-0.74) compared with a smoking score (AUCs 0.80) and was less able to discriminate lung squamous cell carcinoma from adjacent normal tissue (AUC 0.64, 0.52-0.76 versus AUC 0.73, 0.61-0.85). ConclusionsThe DNA methylation profile for e-cigarette use is largely distinct from that of cigarette smoking, did not replicate in independent samples, and was unable to discriminate lung cancer from normal tissue. The extent to which methylation related to long-term e-cigarette use translates into chronic effects requires further investigation. Key MessagesO_ST_ABSWhat is the key question?C_ST_ABSIs there a DNA methylation signature of e-cigarette use and is it distinct from that of smoking? What is the bottom line?Smoke exposure is known to lead to widespread changes in DNA methylation which have been identified in different populations and samples, persist for many years after smoking cessation, and may act as a biomarker for smoking-related disease risk and mortality. Whether a similar methylation profile exists in relation to e-cigarette use has not been widely investigated. Why read on?We obtained saliva samples from 116 e-cigarette users and compared their DNA methylation profile with 117 smokers and 117 non-smokers. The e-cigarette users in this study had a minimal smoking history, and so we were able to distinguish the effects of e-cigarette use from those of smoke exposure. Overall, we found that the methylation profile associated with e-cigarette use is less pronounced and distinct from that associated with cigarette smoking.