Changes in the Role and Mode of Liver Resection for Hepatocellular Carcinoma Over 20 Years: A Single-Center Analysis

The aim of this study was to analyze changes in characteristics of HCC and the modes of LR over 20 years in order to show the impact of those changes in the outcome of LR. In addition, BCLC staging was used to assess the limitations of this classification system and changes over the decade. In our department, 500 liver resections (LR) were performed for hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) over the 20 years between January 2000 and February 2020. The 208 cases performed through 2009 were designated as Era 1, and the 292 cases between 2010 and February 2020 were termed Era 2. We analyzed changes in the characteristics of HCC and mode of LR (Study 1), and final outcomes of LR are shown according to the BCLC staging classifications and eras using data from the 5 years after LR (Study 2). In Era 1, the mean age of the patients was 68, while in Era 2 the mean age was 71, which was significantly older than the patients in Era 1. HCC that developed from non-B, non-C liver cirrhosis was significantly increased in Era 2 (45%) as compared to that in Era 1 (34%). Laboratory data were all comparable between the eras in patients undergoing LR for HCC. The size and numbers of the HCC as well as tumor markers were similar between the eras. As to the mode of LR, although the extent of LR was similar between the eras, the laparoscopic method was significantly increased in Era 2. Blood loss was significantly lower in Era 2 (mean 519 g) than in Era 1 (1,085 g). Patient survival and recurrence-free survival (RFS) were similar between the two eras, while RFS at 5 years after LR was better in Era 2. Even in the BCLC A category, only patients with a single HCC less than 5 cm showed best results, while patients with HCC within the rest of BCLC A and BCLC B showed a dismal outcome. There was no difference in OS and RFS between the eras after stratification by BCLC. There are conspicuous changes in the baseline characteristics and mode of LR over 20 years, which should be taken into account for patient care and informed consent for patients undergoing LR going forward.