Efficacy of brachytherapy for prostate cancer in African Americans compared with Caucasians

Abstract Purpose To compare the biochemical response to prostate brachytherapy between African Americans and Caucasians in a consecutive series of patients treated at a single institution. Methods and materials Between July 1995 and October 2001, 173 patients were treated with permanent 125 I seed implantation alone for presumed localized adenocarcinoma of the prostate. Twelve patients were African American and their biochemical response to treatment was compared with the 161 Caucasian patients. The patients were evaluated for biochemical recurrence according to the ASTRO consensus statement and for achieving and maintaining PSA nadirs of ⩽1.0, ⩽0.5, and ⩽0.2. Median pretreatment PSA level was 8 for the African American group and 6 for the Caucasian group. Median Gleason score for each group was 6 and no patients had palpable extraprostatic disease at the time of treatment. Results None of the African American patients have experienced biochemical recurrence compared with 7.5% of the Caucasian patients ( p  = 0.34). The percentage of African American patients achieving and maintaining a PSA level of ⩽1.0 was 83% compared with 89% for the Caucasian patients ( p  = 0.61). PSA nadir of ⩽0.5 was achieved in 75% of the African American patients and 81% of the Caucasian patients ( p  = 0.52) and 50% of the African American patients experienced PSA levels of ⩽0.2 compared with 59% of the Caucasian patients ( p  = 0.88). Conclusion African American patients with prostate cancer have in general been reported to have worse prognosis compared with Caucasians. This series suggests similar outcome between African American and Caucasian patients treated with brachytherapy for prostate cancer.