Comparison of Rigid-Plastic and Elastoplastic Finite Element Predictions of a Tensile Test of Cylindrical Specimens

In this paper, finite element predictions of a tensile test of cylindrical specimens obtained by rigid-plastic and elastoplastic finite element methods are compared in terms of tensile load-elongation curve and deformed shape. The flow stress curve used for this study is obtained by a scheme of obtaining flow stress at large strain from tensile test of cylindrical specimen using rigid-plastic finite element method. The two predictions are compared in a quantitative manner and discussed not only to find some similarity but also to distinguish the elastoplastic finite element method from the rigid-plastic finite element method.