Examining different outcome measures for reliability in assessing the impact of cataract surgery in quality of health

INTRODUCTION The aim of this study was to determine a reliable combination of vision-specific measures and general health measures to assess the improvement on the patient's QoL following cataract surgery either when patients had first time surgery or had already received successful surgery in the fellow eye for cataract. METHODS Study sample included two waves of data measurement in 150 patients undergoing uncomplicated cataract surgery who were assessed for visual acuity, vision-specific quality of life, and general health. Data were acquired pre-surgery and 2 months post-surgery. About 90 patients haven't had prior cataract surgery while 60 patients had prior successful cataract surgery in the fellow eye. RESULTS There was considerable improvement in all outcome measures following cataract surgery. Patients who have had prior surgery presented with modestly higher scores in the vision-specific QoL measures and minimal benefit pre-operatively compared to those who haven't had any surgery in the general health measure. They also had more gains post-surgery in the vision-specific QoL measures only. CONCLUSIONS There is a possibility that gains in QoL plateau after a certain level of visual acuity improvement. While improvement can be detected with a general health QoL measure, this measure may require additional psychometric validation to the particular population beforehand. Otherwise, a combination of vision-specific outcome measures will provide the most reliable estimate.