Value of intraoperative frozen section examination in the diagnosis and surgical procedures selection of renal occupying lesions

Objective To evaluate the value of intraoperative frozen section examination (IFS) in the diagnosis and surgical procedures selection for renal occupying lesions. Methods From January 2006 to December 2010,IFS was used in 114 men and 81 women with renal occupying lesions.The mean age was 52 years (range 17 -78).In 104,89,and 2 patients,lesions were in the right,left and bilateral kidneys,respectively.All patients underwent physical examination,129 were asymptomatic at presentation while clinical symptoms were observed in 66.The largest dimension of the tumors were 4 cm or less in 128 patients,4- 7 cm in 49,and larger than 7 cm in 18,respectively.The outcomes between IFS and postoperative routine paraffin section examination were compared.In cases with renal tumors nephrectomy or partial nephrectomy was performed.The results of IFS were compared between the 2 groups. Results The sensitivity and specificity of IFS for renal malignant lesions was 96.6％ and 100％,respectively.The total accuracy rate of IFS for renal occupying lesions was 97.4％.By subgroup analysis,the accuracy rate of clear cell carcinoma,papillary cell carcinoma,chromophobe cell carcinoma,sarcomatoid cancer,nephroblastoma,benign tumor and urothelial cancer was 94.3％,25.0％,16.7％,0,0,97.6％ and 100.0％,respectively.Partial nephrectomy and nephrectomy were performed in 57 and 123 patients with renal tumors,respectively.The surgical procedures selection was significantly associated with the lesion size (4 cm or less for 80.7％ vs 62.6％,P =0.015) and the malignant lesion diagnosed by IFS (31.6％ vs 93.5％,P＜0.001). Conclusion The accuracy of frozen section analysis for renal malignant lesions during surgery is reliable and significantly high,and the results can exert an important impact on surgical procedures selection. Key words: Kidney neoplasms ; Pathology, surgical; Frozen sections;  Diagnosis; Nephrectomy