Anterior Leaflet Augmentation With CorMatrix Porcine Extracellular Matrix in Twenty-Five Patients: Unexpected Patch Failures and Histologic Analysis

Background This study reported on the treatment of Carpentier type IIIa and type IIIb mitral regurgitation (MR) with a large patch anterior mitral valve leaflet augmentation technique using CorMatrix (CorMatrix Cardiovascular Inc, Alpharetta, GA) extracellular matrix (ECM). Methods A single-site chart review was conducted on patients who underwent anterior leaflet augmentation performed with the Da Vinci surgical robot (Intuitive Surgical, Sunnyvale, CA) or through a median sternotomy. Only patients who had anterior leaflet augmentation with porcine intestine ECM or autologous pericardium were included. Follow-up echocardiography was performed on all patients. Histologic specimens were available on ECM patches from a subset of patients who required reoperation. Results Between August 2011 and April 2014, 44 patients (mean age, 62.6 ± 12.2 years) underwent anterior leaflet augmentation with either porcine intestinal ECM or autologous pericardium at the Temple University Hospital in Philadelphia. Two (4%) late deaths occurred, one in each group. One patient who underwent ECM augmentation died of non–cardiac-related causes 7 months after discharge as a result of complications of chronic renal failure. The second late death occurred 5 months after discharge because of complications of a stroke in a patient in the pericardial augmentation group. Eight (32%) of the patients with ECM had recurrence of severe MR on echocardiography at an average time of 201 ± 98 days. Seven (28%) patients required reoperation because of failure of the ECM patch including perforation (4%), excessive patch dilation (20%), and suture line dehiscence (4%). In contrast, none of the patients with pericardial augmentation developed severe MR or required operation. Statistical analysis of the patients with ECM augmentation demonstrated no correlation of the following: age; sex; comorbid conditions such as diabetes, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, and hypertension; left ventricular ejection fraction; surgical approach; annuloplasty size; or type of MR with patch failure. A lower body mass index was the only factor associated with recurrent severe regurgitation on univariate analysis ( p  = 0.039). Histologic study of the four available explants demonstrated intense inflammation without evidence of host integration. The remaining 15 (60%) patients had normal mitral leaflet structure and function on follow-up echocardiograms out to 12 months. Conclusions For type III MR, a large anterior leaflet patch technique with porcine ECM was associated with a 32% recurrence rate of severe MR related directly to patch failure. Further research and development should be performed on the use of ECM materials with a goal to decrease the failure rate experienced in this study.